Defense rests in McStay family murder trial, final arguments to begin Tuesday

The defense relaxed Thursday in the months-long capital murder trial of Charles Ray Merritt, charged with fatally bludgeoning the four-member McStay family members of Fallbrook in 2010.

Their bodies were found hidden in the High Desert 3 years later.

Merritt had actually thought about affirming. Yet Judge Michael A. Smith said throughout a hearing outside jurors’ visibility that if Merritt did take the stand he was inclined to enable district attorneys to bring up a string of felony sentences for Merritt, primarily for second-degree theft or receiving swiped residential or commercial property, from 1977 through 2001.

“When there is a proceeding pattern of burglary-theft related issues, that included two state prison dedications and also numerous gives of probation, and the conduct proceeds, I think that matters in judging reputation,” Smith said, according to audio posted on YouTube by the Legislation as well as Criminal Activity Network.

Smith then called a recess for Merritt to think about. His respond to whether he wished to chosen to testify was not audible on the YouTube documents, however moments later on the protection agreed with Smith when he asked if it had relaxed.

Defense lawyer Rajan Maline said he and also protection lawyer James McGee had discussed the matter of testifying with Merritt “and covered all the concerns that we needed to cover.”

Statement started Jan. 7. Final arguments are established to begin Tuesday.

Merritt, 62, has actually begged blameless in the slayings of Joseph McStay, 40, his partner, Summertime, 43, and also their two kids, Gianni, 4, as well as Joseph Jr., 3.

He was detained as well as charged in November 2014– a year after the McStay household’s skeletal remains were discovered in 2 shallow tombs west of the 15 Freeway and north of Stoddard Wells Road, near Victorville. Merritt is a former Apple Valley homeowner.

A three-pound sledge hammer investigators said was used to eliminate the family members was buried along with their remains.

Amongst the evidence heard by jurors in the San Bernardino court room were professionals on cell-phone place pings as well as defense-disputed state-of-the-art analyses of a protection video clip that prosecutors claimed showed Merritt’s work vehicle driving through the McStays’ Fallbrook street the evening they were slain.

The additionally listened to often-complex testament regarding business accounts of Joseph McStay.

McStay as well as Merritt stayed in business together, with McStay, a former San Clemente local, marketing large water functions and Merritt constructing them. District attorneys say Merritt owed money as well as intended to loot McStay’s company accounts.

Defense lawyer said Merritt’s organisation leads with McStay were too profitable to support that concept, which the men were friends. They have claimed an additional company associate of McStay, was a prime suspect that detectives forgotten.

Related Articles


  • Judge transforms down defense movement to dismiss fees in McStay family members murder test


  • Plane on training mission collisions near March Air Get Base; pilot and 12 others hospitalized Male gets 6 years for stealing $ 500,000 worth of surgical staples from health center< a class ="article-title"href =" https://www.ocregister.com/2019/05/01/plane-crashes-in-field-near-cable-airport-in-upland/ "title ="Placentia pilot injured when replica of German WWII Fi-156 plane collisions in area


  • ” > Placentia pilot harmed when replica of German WWII Fi-156 aircraft crashes in area Man located fired on driveway of Yard Grove residence passes away

Leave a Reply